Carbon Steel Cookware Reviews In 2024

By Melissa H. Fenton

January 1,2024

Carbon steel cookware is a popular choice for many home chefs due to its durability and non-stick properties. It’s lightweight, easy to clean and maintain, and it distributes heat evenly across the surface. Carbon steel cookware reviews are mostly favorable with users reporting that their pans offer excellent performance in terms of heat distribution, searing capabilities, and ease of cleaning.

Carbon Steel Cookware Reviews:Some reviewers do mention that carbon steel can be more prone to rusting than other materials if not properly maintained or used correctly. In general though, carbon steel cookware holds up well over time with proper care making it an ideal choice for both home cooks and professional chefs alike.

Carbon Steel Cookware Reviews: Top 5 Picks for Superior Cooking Performance

When it comes to cookware, choosing the right material is crucial for achieving exceptional cooking results. Carbon steel cookware has emerged as a popular choice among professional chefs and home cooks alike. Renowned for its durability, heat retention, and even heat distribution, carbon steel cookware is a versatile addition to any kitchen. In this comprehensive review, we’ll explore the top 5 carbon steel cookware options on the market, delving into their product details, features, pros, and cons to help you make an informed decision.

1.Lodge Seasoned Carbon Steel Skillet:

Check Latest Price On Amazon

Product Details:

• Dimensions: Available in various sizes from 8 inches to 15 inches in diameter.
• Construction: Made from 12-gauge carbon steel for superior durability and long-lasting performance.
• Pre-seasoned: Comes with natural seasoning for a non-stick surface right out of the box.
• Handle: Riveted steel handle for a secure grip and easy maneuvering.
• Suitable for: Ideal for searing, frying, sautéing, and baking.

Features:

• Excellent heat retention: Ensures even cooking and consistent results.
• Versatility: Suitable for use on all cooktops, including induction.
• Oven-safe: Can withstand high temperatures, making it oven-safe up to 500°F (260°C).
• Easy to maintain: Requires minimal maintenance with proper care.
• Affordable: Provides professional-level performance at a reasonable price.

Pros:

• Superior heat distribution for perfect browning and searing.
• Durable construction ensures a long lifespan.
• Suitable for both stovetop and oven use.
• Low maintenance with no synthetic coatings.
• Compatible with metal utensils.

Cons:

• Initial seasoning may require extra effort for optimal non-stick performance.
• Heavier compared to some other cookware materials.
• Handle can get hot during prolonged cooking.

2.Matfer Bourgeat Black Steel Round Frying Pan:

Check Latest Price On Amazon

Product Details:

• Dimensions: Available in various sizes from 8.6 inches to 14.2 inches in diameter.
• Construction: Made from black carbon steel for exceptional heat distribution.
• Pre-seasoned: Requires minimal seasoning before first use.
• Handle: Riveted ergonomic handle for comfortable and secure handling.
• Suitable for: Perfect for high-heat cooking, sautéing, and stir-frying.

Features:

• Quick heating: Reaches high temperatures rapidly, reducing cooking time.
• Lightweight: Easy to handle and maneuver in the kitchen.
• Natural non-stick surface: Develops a patina over time for improved non-stick performance.
• Versatile: Suitable for use on gas, electric, and induction cooktops.
• Excellent heat tolerance: Can withstand high heat without warping.

Pros:

• Professional-grade performance for even cooking.
• Long-lasting and durable construction.
• Minimal maintenance required.
• Compatible with metal utensils.
• Ideal for searing and achieving a restaurant-quality sear on meats.

Cons:

• Initial seasoning is necessary for optimal performance.
• Some users may find the black steel surface less visually appealing.
• Handwashing recommended to preserve the seasoning.

3.de Buyer Mineral B Element Pro Carbon Steel Fry Pan:

Check Latest Price On Amazon

Product Details:

• Dimensions: Available in various sizes from 8 inches to 14.2 inches in diameter.
• Construction: Made from 99% pure iron with a beeswax finish.
• Pre-seasoned: Requires minimal seasoning before use.
• Handle: Sturdy and ergonomic handle for comfortable cooking.
• Suitable for: Ideal for frying, browning, and deglazing.

Features:

• Eco-friendly construction: Crafted from natural materials without chemicals or coatings.
• Versatile: Can be used on any stovetop, including induction.
• Excellent heat distribution: Provides uniform heating across the surface.
• Beeswax coating: Offers natural protection against oxidation and enhances non-stick properties.
• Healthy cooking: Iron leaches into food, adding trace minerals.

Pros:

• Superior heat retention and distribution.
• Durable construction for long-lasting use.
• Chemical-free and environmentally friendly.
• Suitable for high-heat cooking.
• Easy to clean and maintain.

Cons:

• Requires regular seasoning to maintain non-stick properties.
• Heavier compared to some other cookware materials.
• Not dishwasher safe.

4.Mauviel M’Steel Carbon Steel Crepe Pan:

Check Latest Price On Amazon

Product Details:

• Dimensions: Available in a 9.5-inch diameter size.
• Construction: Made from commercial-grade black carbon steel.
• Pre-seasoned: Requires minimal seasoning before use.
• Handle: Riveted steel handle with a French-style design.
• Suitable for: Perfect for making crepes, pancakes, and delicate dishes.

Features:

• Excellent heat responsiveness: Heats up quickly and evenly across the cooking surface.
• Low-profile design: Ideal for flipping and maneuvering delicate foods.
• Durable construction: Built to withstand the rigors of a professional kitchen.
• Versatile: Suitable for all cooktops, including induction.
• Iconic French craftsmanship: Handcrafted in France with meticulous attention to detail.

Pros:

• Precise temperature control for delicate cooking.
• Long-lasting and robust construction.
• Easy to clean and maintain.
• Ideal for achieving thin and perfectly cooked crepes.
• Suitable for high-heat cooking.

Cons:

• Smaller size may not be suitable for larger family meals.
• Not dishwasher safe.
• Requires regular seasoning to maintain non-stick properties.

5.Paderno Heavy-Duty Carbon Steel Wok:

Check Latest Price On Amazon

Product Details:

• Dimensions: Available in a 14-inch diameter size.
• Construction: Made from heavy-duty carbon steel.
• Pre-seasoned: Requires minimal seasoning before first use.
• Handle: Riveted steel handle with a helper handle for easy lifting.
• Suitable for: Ideal for stir-frying, steaming, and deep-frying.

Features:

• Large capacity: Spacious design accommodates generous portions.
• Excellent heat distribution: Ensures even cooking across the entire wok.
• Superior depth: Allows for easy tossing and flipping of ingredients.
• Suitable for high-heat cooking: Can withstand intense heat for authentic stir-frying.
• Versatile: Suitable for use on gas, electric, and induction cooktops.

Pros:

• Robust and sturdy construction for long-lasting use.
• Comfortable and secure grip with the helper handle.
• Ideal for creating restaurant-quality stir-fries.
• Low maintenance with proper care.
• Suitable for high-temperature cooking techniques.

Cons:

• Larger size may not be practical for smaller kitchens or cooking for a few people.
• Heavyweight may require some effort in handling.
• Requires seasoning and proper care to maintain non-stick properties.

Carbon steel cookware offers remarkable cooking performance and durability, making it a favorite among seasoned chefs and cooking enthusiasts. Each of the reviewed products has its unique strengths, providing a variety of options to cater to different cooking preferences and needs. Whether you’re a professional chef or a home cook looking to elevate your culinary experience, investing in carbon steel cookware will undoubtedly be a rewarding decision. Consider the size, features, and pros and cons of each option to find the perfect addition to your kitchen arsenal and enjoy the benefits of superior cooking with carbon steel cookware.

Stainless Steel vs. Carbon Steel Pans: 10 Differences & How to Choose

Carbon steel cookware is gaining popularity among chefs and home cooks alike due to its durability, heat conduction, and affordability. With so many options on the market, it can be difficult to find the right piece of cookware for you. Fortunately, there are numerous reviews available online that provide insight into different carbon steel pieces from brands such as de Buyer, Lodge Cast Iron, and Matfer Bourgeat.

You’ll get a better understanding of what sets each brand apart from one another in terms of quality and performance. After reading some reviews you’ll be able to make an informed decision about which type of carbon steel cookware best suits your needs!

Carbon Steel Cookware Set

Carbon steel is one of the most popular materials for cookware sets. This type of cookware is lightweight, durable and conducts heat quickly. In addition, it also offers a non-stick surface that makes cooking easier.

Carbon steel cookware sets are relatively inexpensive compared to other types of cookware and will last for many years with proper care.

Best Carbon Steel Pan America’S Test Kitchen

America’s Test Kitchen recently tested and rated a variety of carbon steel pans. The top-rated pan was the De Buyer Mineral B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan, which earned an “Excellent” rating for its even heating, durability, and excellent searing capabilities. This French-made pan is lightweight yet strong enough to handle frequent use in the kitchen.

Plus, it has a smooth interior that makes cooking and clean up easy. If you’re looking for a high quality carbon steel pan with superior performance and long lasting results, this one should be at the top of your list!

Made in Carbon Steel Pan

Carbon steel pans are a popular option for home cooks who want to cook up delicious dishes without the fuss of more complicated and expensive materials. Carbon steel is an alloy of iron and carbon that has a higher heat conductivity than other metals, making these pans great for searing meats or sautéing vegetables. They can also be seasoned just like cast-iron skillets, giving them nonstick properties while preserving their durability.

Carbon Steel Pan Vs Cast Iron

Carbon steel pans are a great alternative to traditional cast iron pans. They are much lighter in weight and easier to maneuver, while still providing good heat retention and an even cooking surface. Carbon steel also has improved non-stick properties over its cast iron counterpart, meaning less oil is needed during the cooking process.

Additionally, carbon steel is more corrosion resistant than cast iron, making it easier to clean and maintain. Ultimately, both types of cookware have their own unique benefits; deciding which one is right for you depends on your individual needs as a home chef!

Matfer Bourgeat Carbon Steel Pan

Matfer Bourgeat carbon steel pans are among the most popular cookware for professional chefs. Made from a single sheet of high-quality carbon steel, these pans offer superior heat distribution and retention to ensure an even cooking surface. The pan’s thick walls allow it to be used safely over any type of heat source, including induction stoves, making them more versatile than other types of cookware.

The nonstick finish is easy to clean and won’t flake or peel like some other finishes can. Matfer Bourgeat carbon steel pans are designed for both commercial use as well as home kitchens, so you can enjoy top-notch performance in your own culinary creations!

Smithey Carbon Steel

Smithey Carbon Steel is a high quality and durable material that is perfect for making cookware. It has excellent heat conduction, which helps you to maintain even temperatures while cooking, as well as a naturally non-stick surface. Smithey carbon steel also offers superior corrosion resistance, so it can last a lifetime with proper care and maintenance.

Carbon Steel Cookware Pros And Cons

Carbon steel cookware is a popular choice for many home cooks because of its durability, affordability, and heat retention properties. While carbon steel has some distinct advantages over other materials such as cast iron, it also has some drawbacks that should be considered before making your purchase. On the plus side, carbon steel cookware heats up quickly and evenly which makes it ideal for searing meats or caramelizing vegetables.

It’s lightweight yet sturdy so you can move pots and pans around with ease without worrying about them breaking or cracking. Additionally, since carbon steel is non-porous it doesn’t absorb flavors from foods like aluminum does which means you don’t have to worry about strange tastes in whatever dish you make. On the downside however, due to its high reactivity with acids and alkalis (such as tomato sauces), food often sticks easily causing burnt bits on the bottom of the pan if not stirred regularly while cooking; this requires more attention than traditional nonstick surfaces do when cooking certain dishes.

De Buyer Carbon Steel

De Buyer Carbon Steel is a type of cookware made from a combination of iron and carbon. This material has been used for centuries by professional chefs to create delicious meals, as it conducts heat evenly and quickly, allowing for precise control over cooking temperatures. It’s also incredibly durable and will last for many years if properly cared for, making it an ideal choice for the home chef looking to invest in quality cookware.

Credit: www.simplyrecipes.com

What are the Downsides of Carbon Steel Pans?

Despite the many benefits of carbon steel pans, they come with some downsides that are worth considering. Carbon steel pans can be more difficult to take care of due to their higher reactivity. While these pots and pans may develop a patina over time that adds flavor and prevents food from sticking, it also means they’re prone to rusting if not dried properly after washing.

As such, you must carefully dry the pan before storing so as not to damage it. Additionally, unlike non-stick cookware which is often dishwasher safe, carbon steel should never be placed in the dishwasher since the harsh detergents used can ruin them quickly. Furthermore, because of their hardness and weight compared to other types of cookware like aluminum or stainless steel pots and pans, using a carbon steel pan requires more effort when cooking certain foods like scrambled eggs or omelettes as they tend to stick more easily without proper seasoning beforehand or generous amounts oil being used throughout the cooking process.

Are Carbon Steel Pans Any Good?

Carbon steel pans are becoming increasingly popular in the home kitchen. They offer a number of benefits over other types of cookware, such as being lightweight, durable and easy to maintain. Carbon steel pans also provide superior heat distribution when compared to cast iron or stainless steel pans, resulting in more even cooking temperatures.

In addition, carbon steel is less likely to react with acidic ingredients like tomatoes and vinegar than either cast iron or stainless steel which can help protect your food from tasting metallic. The thin design of carbon steel allows for reduced cooking time since it heats up quickly compared to thicker materials like cast iron. Furthermore, because they are so light weight they’re perfect for camping trips or picnics where you don’t want an overly heavy piece of cookware taking up too much space in your pack!

All that said however, there are some downsides associated with carbon steel: It requires frequent seasoning (or oiling) in order to prevent rust; it may not be suitable if you have any sensitivity towards metal utensils; and lastly it will discolour easily if exposed to high heat without proper care. Overall though, we think that carbon-steel pans make a great choice for those looking for an affordable yet reliable option – just remember the maintenance tips above and you should be able enjoy many years of delicious meals cooked on your new pan!

Which is Better Stainless Clad Or Carbon Steel?

When it comes to choosing between stainless clad or carbon steel, the choice depends on what you need the metal for. Stainless clad is a composite of two metals – stainless steel and carbon steel – with layers of each metal bonded together. This gives it superior strength, durability and corrosion resistance compared to pure stainless steel or carbon steel.

That said, depending on your application, one type may be better than the other. For applications that require high strength but are not subject to corrosive environments (such as outdoor use), then carbon steel is typically preferred due to its greater strength-to-weight ratio over stainless clad. For example, structural beams used in construction would typically be made from carbon rather than stainless clad because they need to bear heavy loads without corroding away quickly.

However, for projects that will be exposed to moisture or harsh chemicals like saltwater, then a combination of both materials may be preferable since stainless has greater corrosion resistance compared to plain carbon steel alone. In this case, using a layer of stainless sandwiched between two layers of mild (low-carbon) steel can provide superior durability against rusting while still providing good strength and weight savings compared with all-stainless components. Overall there’s no clear “winner” when it comes down deciding which is better: Stainless Clad or Carbon Steel -–it really comes down what your specific project requires and how you plan on using these metals in order get the best possible results!

Do Professional Chefs Use Carbon Steel Pans?

Yes, professional chefs do use carbon steel pans. Carbon steel is a type of metal alloy that consists mainly of iron and a small amount of carbon. This combination makes it incredibly tough and resistant to corrosion while also giving it excellent heat conduction properties.

Carbon steel pans are lightweight yet strong enough to withstand high temperatures without warping or buckling, making them ideal for searing meats, sautéing vegetables, and creating delicate sauces. Their non-stick surface allows food to be cooked with minimal oil or butter which makes them great for healthy cooking as well. They’re also easy to clean since all you need is hot water and dish soap – no special cleaning agents required!

With the right care, these pans can last generations so they’re definitely worth investing in if you want quality results every time you cook.

Buying Guide Of Carbon Steel Cookware

When it comes to investing in cookware, carbon steel is a popular choice among professional chefs and home cooks alike. With its excellent heat retention, durability, and versatility, carbon steel cookware can elevate your culinary experience. However, with a wide variety of options available, it’s essential to consider several factors before making your purchase. This comprehensive buying guide will help you understand the key aspects of carbon steel cookware and make an informed decision.

1. Understanding Carbon Steel: Carbon steel is an alloy composed primarily of iron and carbon. It is similar to cast iron in terms of its heat retention and distribution properties but is much lighter in weight, making it easier to handle in the kitchen. The carbon content affects the hardness and performance of the cookware.
2. Benefits of Carbon Steel Cookware: Carbon steel offers numerous advantages, including excellent heat conductivity, even heat distribution, and responsiveness to temperature changes. It heats up quickly and maintains a consistent temperature, making it perfect for searing, frying, and sautéing. Additionally, it develops a natural non-stick patina over time, enhancing its cooking performance.
3. Cookware Types: Carbon steel cookware comes in various forms, including frying pans, sauté pans, woks, and crepe pans. Each type serves specific cooking purposes, so consider the dishes you frequently prepare to choose the right type for your needs.
4. Size and Capacity: Selecting the right size and capacity is crucial. A larger family or those who entertain guests often might prefer bigger pans, while smaller ones may suit individuals or couples. Consider the storage space in your kitchen and ensure the cookware fits comfortably in your cabinets.
5. Thickness and Gauge: The thickness of carbon steel cookware affects its performance. Thicker pans may provide more even heating, but they also take longer to heat up. The gauge number indicates the thickness, with lower gauge numbers being thicker. For most home cooks, a gauge of 10-12 is ideal, striking a balance between performance and weight.
6. Handles: Handles can significantly impact the cookware’s usability and safety. Look for ergonomic, heat-resistant handles that are securely attached to the pan. Riveted or welded handles are more durable than those attached with screws.
7. Lids: Not all carbon steel cookware comes with lids, but having one can be beneficial for certain cooking methods. Lids help trap heat and steam, reducing cooking times and preventing splatters. Ensure that the lid fits securely on the pan.
8. Seasoning: Most carbon steel cookware arrives unseasoned, meaning it lacks a natural non-stick coating. Seasoning involves coating the surface with oil and baking it to create a protective layer. Some manufacturers offer pre-seasoned options, while others require you to season the cookware yourself. Consider your willingness to undertake this process when choosing cookware.
9. Brand and Quality: Choose reputable brands known for producing high-quality carbon steel cookware. Read customer reviews and testimonials to gauge the performance and durability of the product. High-quality cookware may cost more initially but tends to last longer and provide better cooking results.
10. Maintenance: Carbon steel cookware requires proper care to maintain its performance and prevent rusting. Avoid using abrasive cleaning agents and metal utensils, as they can damage the seasoning. Instead, opt for wooden or silicone utensils and use gentle cleaning methods to preserve the patina.
11. Price and Budget: Carbon steel cookware can vary significantly in price, depending on the brand, size, and quality. Set a budget before shopping and consider the long-term investment of durable cookware versus cheaper options that may need replacing sooner.
12. Warranty: Check for warranties offered by the manufacturer. A good warranty can provide peace of mind, knowing that the company stands behind the quality of their product.
13. Induction Compatibility: If you have an induction cooktop, ensure that the carbon steel cookware is compatible with this cooking method. Not all carbon steel pans work on induction stoves, so verify this feature before purchasing.

In conclusion, purchasing carbon steel cookware requires thoughtful consideration of various factors such as type, size, thickness, handles, lids, and maintenance requirements. By understanding these aspects and comparing different brands and models, you can find the perfect carbon steel cookware that meets your cooking needs, budget, and preferences. Properly cared for, high-quality carbon steel cookware can become a valuable and cherished part of your kitchen arsenal, elevating your culinary adventures to new heights.

Conclusion

Overall, carbon steel cookware is a great option for any home cook who is looking to take their cooking skills to the next level. It has many advantages over other types of cookware and will last you years if taken care of properly. With its even heat distribution, quick response to temperature changes, and non-stick surface, this type of pan can help you create delicious meals all at an affordable price.

Whether you’re a beginner or experienced chef, carbon steel cookware should be highly considered as it has been proven time and again that it provides superior results in the kitchen.