Stove rope glue secures your kitchen’s seal, preventing costly heat loss and keeping your home comfortably warm.
Stove rope glue offers a secure, long-lasting seal for your fireplace or stove.Choose a product that is heat-resistant and specifically designed for stove gasket applications for optimal performance and safety.
Recommended Products
Detailed Stove Rope Glue Reviews
Each of these stove rope glue models has been carefully evaluated based on specifications, user feedback, and value proposition. Here are the detailed reviews:
1. Wood Silicone Wood Stove Door Seal
Key Features That Stand Out
The Wood Silicone Wood Stove Door Seal and stove rope glue offer a robust solution for maintaining an efficient wood stove.
- High-temperature resistance up to 500°F (260°C).
- Flexible and durable silicone formula designed for sealing stove doors.
- Provides an airtight seal, preventing smoke and heat escape.
- Easy application process for a secure and long-lasting bond.
- Specially formulated for use with stove door rope seals.
Why Recommended
- Ensures improved heating efficiency by minimizing air leaks.
- Helps to reduce creosote buildup by maintaining a consistent burn.
- The specialized stove rope glue creates a reliable and long-lasting seal.
- Contributes to a safer operating environment by preventing smoke intrusion.
Performance Analysis
- Users report a significant reduction in smoke and drafts after application.
- The glue adheres well to various stove rope materials.
- Maintains its sealing properties even under repeated heating and cooling cycles.
- Dries to a flexible yet firm bond that doesn’t crack.
Best For
- Best for homeowners looking to repair or replace their wood stove door seals.
- Individuals seeking to improve the performance and safety of older wood stoves.
- DIY enthusiasts performing regular maintenance on their heating appliances.
2. Wood High Heat Silicone Sealant
Key Features That Stand Out
The Wood High Heat Silicone Sealant, also known as stove rope glue, offers robust solutions for high-temperature sealing needs. This adhesive is formulated to withstand extreme conditions, making it ideal for specific applications.
- High-Temperature Resistance: Capable of withstanding temperatures up to 3000°F (1650°C).
- Fast Curing Time: Sets quickly, allowing for efficient repairs.
- Durable Bond Strength: Creates a permanent and secure seal.
- Easy Application: Comes in a convenient tube for precise application.
Why Recommended
- This stove rope glue provides a reliable and long-lasting seal for areas exposed to intense heat.
- It ensures a tight seal, preventing smoke and draft leakage from stoves and fireplaces.
- Its high-temperature tolerance means enhanced safety and efficiency for heating appliances.
- The durable bond prevents the need for frequent reapplication, saving time and effort.
Performance Analysis
- Users report that the sealant effectively adheres to stove door gaskets and other high-heat components.
- The material remains flexible enough to accommodate thermal expansion and contraction without cracking.
- It dries to a hard, durable finish that withstands repeated heating and cooling cycles.
- Application is straightforward, allowing for neat and precise sealing around irregularly shaped parts.
Best For
- Best for replacing or repairing fiberglass and ceramic rope seals on wood stoves and fireplace doors.
- Ideal for sealing gaps and cracks in areas subjected to direct flame or extremely high operating temperatures.
- Suitable for DIY enthusiasts and professionals needing a specialized high-heat adhesive.
3. High High Heat Silicone Sealant 2 Pack
Key Features That Stand Out
The High High Heat Silicone Sealant 2 Pack is designed as a durable stove rope glue for high-temperature applications.
- Withstands temperatures up to 5000 degrees Fahrenheit.
- Forms a flexible, airtight seal.
- Dries to a hard, non-corrosive finish.
- Water-resistant once cured.
Why Recommended
- Provides a strong bond for replacing damaged stove door gaskets.
- Effectively seals gaps and prevents heat loss, improving appliance efficiency.
- The high-temperature resistance makes it ideal for demanding stove environments.
- Easy application for a secure and lasting seal with the stove rope glue.
Performance Analysis
- Users report a firm hold on rope seals, maintaining their position effectively.
- The sealant cures without cracking or becoming brittle under heat.
- Achieves an excellent airtight seal, significantly reducing smoke or heat leakage.
- A small amount goes a long way, offering good value from each tube.
Best For
- Homeowners needing to repair or replace seals on wood-burning stoves and fireplaces.
- DIY enthusiasts looking for a reliable adhesive for high-heat repairs.
- Restoring the airtightness and efficiency of older heating appliances.
4. Rutland Fiberglass Stove Gasket Cement
Key Features That Stand Out
When it comes to securing your stove’s fiberglass gasket, Rutland Fiberglass Stove Gasket Cement acts as a reliable stove rope glue. Here’s what makes it noteworthy:
- High-temperature resistance, designed to withstand extreme heat.
- Creates a strong, airtight seal for improved stove efficiency.
- Easy-to-apply paste consistency for convenient application.
- Forms a permanent bond once cured.
Why Recommended
- Ensures your stove door seals properly, preventing heat loss and improving fuel efficiency.
- This effective stove rope glue helps maintain the integrity of your stove’s gasket, reducing smoke and creosote buildup.
- Provides a long-lasting solution for gasket repairs, saving on frequent replacements.
- Its specialized formula is designed for the unique demands of wood-burning stoves.
Performance Analysis
- Users report a solid, durable bond that holds up well over time and through many heating cycles.
- The cement applies smoothly, making it simple to get an even coat on the gasket and stove door.
- It cures to a hard, heat-resistant finish that effectively seals gaps.
- A little goes a long way, offering good value for the quantity provided.
Best For
- Best for homeowners needing to replace or re-secure the fiberglass gasket on their wood-burning stoves.
- Ideal for DIY enthusiasts looking for a dependable product for stove maintenance.
- Suitable for anyone seeking to maintain an efficient and safe wood-burning appliance.
5. Wood Wood Stove Gasket with Cement
Key Features That Stand Out
The Wood Wood Stove Gasket with Cement and its included stove rope glue offer a comprehensive solution for sealing stove doors.
- Comes with a durable, high-temperature resistant gasket material.
- Includes a specialized stove rope glue designed for secure adhesion.
- Available in various thicknesses to fit different stove models.
- Provides a tight seal to prevent air leaks and improve stove efficiency.
Why Recommended
- Effectively stops smoke and drafts, leading to a safer and more efficient burn.
- The included stove rope glue ensures a lasting bond, reducing the need for frequent replacements.
- Helps maintain optimal heat within the stove, contributing to better fuel economy.
- Simple application process makes it accessible for DIY repairs.
Performance Analysis
- The gasket material holds up well under repeated high heat cycles.
- Adhesion from the glue is strong and doesn’t degrade quickly.
- Effectively seals gaps, stopping noticeable drafts.
- Users report a significant improvement in stove performance after installation.
Best For
- Best for homeowners experiencing smoke leaks or draft issues from their wood stove doors.
- Ideal for individuals seeking a reliable, DIY repair solution for aged or damaged stove gaskets.
- Suitable for most standard wood stove models requiring a secure door seal.
6. 2500°F High Temp Stove Gasket Cement
Key Features That Stand Out
The 2500°F High Temp Stove Gasket Cement acts as a robust stove rope glue, offering superior adhesion for critical sealing applications.
- Withstands extreme temperatures up to 2500°F for durability in high-heat environments.
- Forms a strong, airtight seal that prevents smoke and heat leaks.
- Quick-drying formula allows for efficient application and use.
- Designed for use with various stove rope materials, ensuring versatility.
Why Recommended
This product is highly recommended for its reliable performance in maintaining the integrity of wood stoves and similar heating appliances.
- Effectively seals gaps and cracks, contributing to improved heating efficiency.
- The specialized stove rope glue ensures long-lasting adhesion, reducing the need for frequent reapplication.
- Provides a safer operating environment by preventing hazardous fume escape.
- Its high-temperature resistance makes it suitable for the demanding conditions of wood-burning stoves.
Performance Analysis
Users report that the 2500°F High Temp Stove Gasket Cement delivers on its promises of strong adhesion and high-temperature resilience.
- Creates a durable bond that holds up well under repeated heating and cooling cycles.
- The cement dries to a hard, flexible consistency, allowing for slight movement without compromising the seal.
- Effectively seals worn or damaged door gaskets, restoring a tight fit.
- Application is straightforward, allowing for a neat and secure gasket installation.
Best For
This cement is an excellent choice for specific repair and maintenance tasks.
- Best for homeowners and professionals needing to replace or repair wood stove door gaskets.
- Ideal for sealing firebricks or other components within high-temperature appliances.
- Suitable for anyone requiring a reliable adhesive for critical sealing applications in extreme heat.
7. Protalwell Fiberglass wood stove gasket kit
Key Features That Stand Out
The Protalwell Fiberglass wood stove gasket kit, when paired with its included stove rope glue, offers essential components for maintaining your wood stove’s seal. Key features include:
- High-temperature resistant fiberglass for durability in demanding stove environments.
- Generous gasket length provided to accommodate various stove door sizes.
- Adhesive specifically formulated for high heat applications, ensuring a secure bond.
- Easy-to-follow instructions included for straightforward installation.
Why Recommended
- It helps restore an airtight seal to your wood stove door, improving efficiency and reducing smoke leakage.
- The included stove rope glue is designed for longevity and reliable adhesion, preventing premature gasket failure.
- It provides a cost-effective solution for DIY stove maintenance compared to professional servicing.
- Properly installed, it can lead to improved heat retention within your home.
Performance Analysis
- The fiberglass rope effectively withstands the high temperatures generated by wood burning.
- Users report that the glue creates a strong and lasting bond for the gasket.
- The kit’s components are generally seen as adequate for standard wood stove door sealing needs.
- Proper surface preparation is noted as crucial for achieving optimal adhesion with the glue.
Best For
- Homeowners performing routine maintenance on their wood stoves to ensure optimal performance.
- DIY enthusiasts looking for an accessible kit to replace worn or damaged stove door gaskets.
- Individuals seeking to improve their wood stove’s efficiency and reduce air leaks.
8. NQEUEPN Fireplace Stove Door Seal Rope
Key Features That Stand Out
The NQEUEPN Fireplace Stove Door Seal Rope, paired with its dedicated stove rope glue, offers a robust solution for sealing hearth appliances.
- High-temperature adhesive designed for extreme heat applications.
- Forms a durable, airtight seal to prevent smoke and drafts.
- Compatible with various stove rope materials, including fiberglass and ceramic.
- Quick-drying formula for efficient application and use.
Why Recommended
- Restores airtightness to drafty fireplace doors, improving heating efficiency.
- Prevents dangerous smoke leaks, ensuring a safer home environment.
- Provides a long-lasting bond that withstands repeated heating and cooling cycles.
- The specific stove rope glue ensures optimal adhesion and longevity for the seal.
Performance Analysis
- Users report a strong and effective seal after application, significantly reducing drafts.
- The glue holds the rope securely in place, even under intense heat.
- Application is straightforward, allowing for DIY repairs without professional help.
- The resulting seal is noted for its durability over multiple burning seasons.
Best For
- Homeowners needing to replace worn-out or damaged fireplace door seals.
- Individuals seeking to improve the efficiency and safety of their wood-burning stoves.
- Anyone looking for a reliable and easy-to-use adhesive for high-heat sealing applications.
9. Wood Wood Stove Door Gasket Cement
Key Features That Stand Out
When looking for reliable Wood Wood Stove Door Gasket Cement and stove rope glue, this product offers several noteworthy characteristics.
- High-temperature resistance, rated for up to 1200°F.
- Forms a strong, durable bond with glass and metal surfaces.
- Water-based formula for easy cleanup and minimal fumes.
- Provides a tight seal for improved stove efficiency.
Why Recommended
- Ensures a long-lasting repair that prevents drafts and heat loss.
- A cost-effective solution for extending the life of your stove without full replacement.
- The adhesive nature of this stove rope glue makes installation straightforward for DIYers.
- Contributes to safer stove operation by ensuring the door seals properly.
Performance Analysis
- Users report consistent adhesion even under extreme heat cycles.
- The cement dries to a firm but slightly flexible state, accommodating thermal expansion.
- Holds gasket rope securely, preventing it from dislodging during operation.
- Generally performs well in maintaining a smokeless seal for extended periods.
Best For
- Best for homeowners needing to repair or replace their wood stove door gasket.
- Ideal for maintaining the efficiency and safety of wood-burning stoves, pellet stoves, and fireplace inserts.
- Suitable for users seeking a durable and easy-to-apply solution for sealing stove doors.
10. Oven Heat Resistant Glue
Key Features That Stand Out
The Oven Heat Resistant Glue, specifically designed as a stove rope glue, offers several notable attributes for high-temperature applications.
- Achieves a maximum temperature resistance of 1500°F (815°C), making it suitable for intense heat environments.
- Forms a strong, permanent bond that remains durable under thermal stress.
- Non-toxic and fume-free once cured, ensuring a safer application process.
- Provides excellent adhesion to a variety of materials including fiberglass, ceramic, and mineral wool.
Why Recommended
- It’s an ideal solution for securely attaching door seals and insulation where high heat is a constant factor, making this stove rope glue a practical choice.
- Offers a reliable and long-lasting seal, preventing heat loss and improving appliance efficiency.
- Its easy application process means DIY repairs are straightforward, saving time and potential service costs.
- The ability to withstand extreme temperatures ensures the repair’s integrity, providing peace of mind.
Performance Analysis
- Users report the glue effectively secures stove door gaskets, holding firm even after repeated heating and cooling cycles.
- The bond is consistently described as rigid and durable, resisting crumbling or detachment under normal operating conditions.
- Application is typically straightforward, with the glue spreading evenly and setting within the recommended timeframe.
- Its performance holds up well in consistently high-heat environments, as expected for a specialized heat-resistant adhesive.
Best For
- Best for sealing and insulating wood stoves, pellet stoves, and ovens where high temperatures are common.
- Ideal for DIY enthusiasts undertaking appliance repair or maintenance.
- Suitable for professionals needing a dependable adhesive for heat-resistant sealing applications.
11. Red Fireplace & Stove Repair Sealant
Key Features That Stand Out
When dealing with fireplace and stove maintenance, Red Fireplace & Stove Repair Sealant, a specialized stove rope glue, offers several notable characteristics.
- Forms a high-temperature resistant bond, crucial for stove environments.
- Provides a flexible yet durable seal once cured.
- Comes in an easy-to-apply tube for precise application.
- Designed for adhesion to various materials common in stoves, like glass and metal.
Why Recommended
This product excels in practical applications, making it a go-to for specific repairs.
- Ensures a tight seal, preventing heat and smoke leakage, which is vital for safety and efficiency.
- Its reliable adhesion means long-lasting repairs, reducing the frequency of maintenance.
- The specific formulation of this stove rope glue is optimized for the extreme conditions found in fireplaces and stoves.
- Offers a cost-effective solution compared to full component replacement.
Performance Analysis
- The sealant cures to a firm consistency that holds rope seals securely in place.
- It withstands significant heat cycling without degrading or losing its adhesive properties.
- User feedback often highlights its ease of application and effectiveness in sealing small gaps.
- The bond remains intact even with repeated use of the appliance.
Best For
- Best for sealing and re-adhering glass gasket rope on stove doors.
- Ideal for repairing minor damage or loose sections of door seals on wood stoves and fireplaces.
- Suitable for DIY enthusiasts needing a reliable adhesive for high-heat applications.
12. Meeco’s High-Temperature Gasket Cement
Key Features That Stand Out
Meeco’s High-Temperature Gasket Cement is a reliable stove rope glue designed for demanding applications.
- Withstands temperatures up to 2000°F.
- Creates a strong, durable bond for gasket materials.
- Easy-to-apply paste consistency.
- Fast-drying formula for quick repairs.
Why Recommended
- Ensures a tight seal, preventing heat loss and smoke leaks from stoves and fireplaces.
- Excellent adhesion to various gasket types, including fiberglass and ceramic rope.
- The high-temperature resistance means it won’t degrade under extreme stove operating conditions.
- Applying this stove rope glue can significantly extend the life of your appliance’s sealing components.
Performance Analysis
- Users report a secure bond that holds up well over time, even with frequent use of the appliance.
- The cement dries to a rigid, yet slightly flexible, state, allowing for minor expansion and contraction.
- Application is straightforward, making it accessible for DIY repairs.
- Effectively seals gaps and prevents air infiltration, improving efficiency.
Best For
- Best for repairing or replacing door gaskets on wood stoves, pellet stoves, and fireplace inserts.
- Ideal for sealing other high-temperature joints and connections in combustion appliances.
- Suitable for DIY enthusiasts and professionals seeking a dependable sealing solution.
13. Rutland Black Flexible Latex Sealant
Key Features That Stand Out
Rutland Black Flexible Latex Sealant stands out as a reliable stove rope glue solution.
- Specifically formulated for high-temperature applications, making it ideal for stove doors.
- Provides a strong, flexible bond that accommodates thermal expansion and contraction.
- Dries to a tough, durable seal that resists heat and soot.
- Black color blends seamlessly with most stove rope and fireback materials.
Why Recommended
- Ensures a tight seal on stove doors, improving efficiency and reducing drafts.
- The flexible nature of the sealant prevents the bond from cracking under repeated heating and cooling cycles, prolonging the life of your stove rope.
- Easy to apply, making it a practical solution for DIY repairs of your stove rope glue needs.
- Offers excellent adhesion to various stove components.
Performance Analysis
- Users report a secure hold that lasts through multiple heating seasons.
- The sealant dries relatively quickly, allowing for minimal downtime.
- Maintains its integrity even when exposed to significant heat, preventing leaks.
- The black color effectively conceals the applied glue, maintaining a clean aesthetic.
Best For
- Best for homeowners looking to replace worn or damaged stove door rope seals.
- Individuals performing routine maintenance on wood-burning or multi-fuel stoves.
- Repairs requiring a durable, heat-resistant adhesive for flexible materials.
14. Red Red RTV Silicone Sealant, Heat Resistant
Key Features That Stand Out
The Red Red RTV Silicone Sealant, Heat Resistant is a specialized stove rope glue designed for high-temperature applications.
- Excellent heat resistance up to 600°F (315°C).
- Forms a durable, flexible seal.
- Adheres well to common stove materials like metal and ceramic.
- Non-sagging formula for easy application on vertical surfaces.
- Quick curing time for minimal downtime.
Why Recommended
- Provides a reliable seal for stove door gaskets, preventing heat loss and improving efficiency.
- The high-temperature resistance ensures the bond holds even under extreme stove operating conditions, making it an ideal stove rope glue.
- Its flexibility allows for expansion and contraction of materials without cracking or failing, leading to a long-lasting repair.
- Easy to use, allowing for DIY repairs without specialized tools, offering a cost-effective solution.
Performance Analysis
- Users report a strong, secure bond that withstands repeated heating and cooling cycles.
- The red color provides a visible indicator of the applied sealant, aiding in consistent application.
- Effectively prevents smoke and draft leakage once fully cured.
- Holds up well against regular cleaning and maintenance of the stove.
Best For
- Homeowners looking to repair or replace stove door rope seals on wood-burning or pellet stoves.
- DIY enthusiasts seeking a reliable adhesive for high-heat environments.
- Anyone needing to create a durable, heat-resistant seal on metal or ceramic surfaces in similar applications.
15. Fiberglass Fiberglass Boiler Tape
Key Features That Stand Out
The Fiberglass Fiberglass Boiler Tape and associated stove rope glue offer a robust solution for sealing and repair.
- High-temperature resistance, suitable for demanding stove environments.
- Excellent adhesion properties for secure sealing.
- Durable fiberglass construction for longevity.
- Easy to apply with the included adhesive.
Why Recommended
- Effectively seals gaps and cracks in wood stoves, fireplaces, and boilers, improving efficiency.
- The specialized stove rope glue ensures a strong bond that withstands heat cycles.
- Provides a cost-effective alternative to full replacement of worn seals.
- Contributes to a safer heating environment by preventing smoke leakage.
Performance Analysis
- Users report successful application and a significant reduction in air leaks after use.
- The tape holds up well under sustained high temperatures, a critical factor for stove applications.
- Adhesion remains strong over time, preventing the need for frequent reapplication.
- Minimal shrinkage or degradation observed even after extended periods of operation.
Best For
- Homeowners needing to repair or replace door seals on wood-burning stoves.
- Individuals working on routine maintenance for boilers and furnaces where heat sealing is required.
- DIY enthusiasts seeking a reliable solution for fireplace gasket repairs.
16. Stove Self-Adhesive Stove Rope Seal
Key Features That Stand Out
The Stove Self-Adhesive Stove Rope Seal and stove rope glue offer a straightforward solution for sealing your stove.
- High-temperature resistance up to 500°C (932°F).
- Fast-drying formula ensures a quick and secure bond.
- Forms a durable, airtight seal once cured.
- Easy application with a user-friendly design.
Why Recommended
- Effectively prevents heat loss and improves stove efficiency.
- The self-adhesive nature of the rope seal, combined with the stove rope glue, makes installation simpler and faster than traditional methods.
- Creates a safe environment by preventing smoke leaks and ensuring proper combustion.
- Provides a long-lasting seal that withstands the rigors of regular stove use.
Performance Analysis
- Users report a strong bond that holds the rope securely in place.
- The seal remains intact even under prolonged high heat conditions.
- Application is generally mess-free, with the glue spreading evenly.
- The cured seal effectively stops drafts and improves the overall performance of the stove.
Best For
- Best for DIY enthusiasts looking for a reliable way to replace worn or damaged stove door seals.
- Owners of wood-burning stoves, multifuel stoves, orAGA-style cookers that require regular rope maintenance.
- Individuals seeking an efficient and cost-effective method for resealing their appliance.
How to Choose the Perfect Stove Rope Glue
Selecting the right stove rope glue is crucial for ensuring a secure and long-lasting seal for your wood-burning stove door. The difference between a good and a great adhesive lies in its ability to withstand high temperatures, maintain its flexibility, and adhere effectively to various stove materials.
Key Features to Look For
- High-temperature resistance (specify temperature range if known, e.g., up to 800°C)
- Excellent adhesion to metal, ceramic, and firebrick
- Flexibility to accommodate expansion and contraction of stove components
- Durable and long-lasting bond
Important Materials
The quality of the materials used in stove rope glue significantly impacts its performance and lifespan. Look for adhesives formulated with inorganic binders and fillers designed for high-heat applications. Avoid glues that contain solvents or organic compounds, as these can degrade and become brittle or even flammable at stove operating temperatures. A good quality glue will maintain its integrity even after repeated heating and cooling cycles.
Essential Factors to Consider
When selecting stove rope glue, consider its application method for ease of use. Some glues come in convenient tubes with applicator tips, while others may require a separate putty knife or spatula. The drying and curing times are also important, as you’ll want the seal to be robust enough for stove operation within a reasonable timeframe. Always check the manufacturer’s instructions for specific application guidelines.
Budget Planning
| Category | Description | Typical Features |
|---|---|---|
| Budget-Friendly | Basic adhesives suitable for occasional repairs or less demanding stove use. | Standard temperature resistance, moderate adhesion, shorter lifespan. |
| Mid-Range | Balanced performance and durability for regular stove operation. | Good to high temperature resistance, strong adhesion, moderate to long lifespan. |
| Premium | Top-tier adhesives offering exceptional performance and longevity for demanding applications. | Very high temperature resistance, superior adhesion, extended lifespan, often specialized formulations. |
When to Buy
The best time to purchase stove rope glue often coincides with seasonal sales events, such as end-of-year clearances or spring/fall appliance promotions. Planning your purchase ahead of the colder months can help you secure better prices and ensure you have the necessary materials for maintenance before the heating season begins. Keep an eye out for discounts from hardware stores and online retailers.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is stove rope glue used for?
Stove rope glue, like Rutland Fiberglass Stove Gasket Cement or Protalwell Fiberglass wood stove gasket kit, secures stove door seals and gaskets to prevent heat and smoke leaks.
Which stove rope glues are best for high heat applications?
Products such as 2500°F High Temp Stove Gasket Cement and Meeco’s High-Temperature Gasket Cement are formulated for extreme temperatures encountered in wood stoves.
Can I use stove rope glue for fireplace repairs?
Yes, Red Fireplace & Stove Repair Sealant and Rutland Black Flexible Latex Sealant can be used for sealing fireplace components and stove doors.
What’s the difference between silicone sealants and gasket cement for stoves?
Silicone sealants like Wood High Heat Silicone Sealant offer flexibility, while gasket cements, such as Wood Wood Stove Gasket with Cement, provide a rigid bond for gaskets.
Are there self-adhesive options for stove rope?
Yes, Stove Self-Adhesive Stove Rope Seal provides a convenient, pre-glued application, eliminating the need for separate stove rope glue.
Conclusion
This stove rope glue ensures a secure seal. The reviewed options offer reliable adhesion for your stove, restoring optimal performance and safety.
Ready to Choose Your Perfect Stove Rope Glue?
Browse our expert-tested stove rope glue recommendations above and find the perfect match for your gaming setup!
Leave a Reply